Case title | Mountain Valley Springs India Private Limited vs Assistant Commissioner |
Court | Karnataka High Court |
Honorable Judges | Justice Vineet Kothari |
Citation | 2018 (09) GSTPanacea 15 HC karnataka WRIT PETITION NO.32774 OF 2018 (T-RES) |
Judgement Date | 24-september-2018 |
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.
the petitioner began by outlining the intricacies of the case. With a demeanor that exuded confidence and expertise, the counsel delved into the crux of the matter, meticulously dissecting each legal argument with precision. Drawing upon precedent cases and statutory provisions, they constructed a formidable defense for their client.
As the proceedings unfolded, the courtroom became a theater of legal discourse, with the counsel skillfully weaving together a narrative that captivated the attention of all present. With each point articulated, the gravity of the issue at hand became increasingly apparent, underscoring the importance of a just resolution.
With eloquence and conviction, the counsel highlighted the fundamental principles of law that underpinned their case, demonstrating a profound understanding of the intricacies of the legal system. Their arguments were not merely persuasive; they were compelling, leaving no room for doubt regarding the righteousness of their cause.
In response to the notice issued by the court to the respondent-Department, the counsel’s presentation was nothing short of masterful. They navigated through the complexities of the case with finesse, leaving an indelible impression on all those in attendance. With each argument meticulously crafted and flawlessly delivered, they paved the way for a long summer of legal deliberation, wherein justice would ultimately prevail.
Long Summer I: The Case of Notification No.48/2018
In the hazy heat of a midsummer’s day, the courtroom buzzed with anticipation as the honorable judge took his seat, ready to preside over another case of legal intricacies. On this particular day, the matter at hand revolved around Notification No.48/2018 Central Tax, a document that held the key to unraveling a complex web of taxation regulations.
As the proceedings commenced, the courtroom was filled with an air of solemnity, punctuated only by the occasional shuffle of papers and the steady murmur of voices engaged in legal discourse. The petitioner, a diligent advocate seeking clarity on the implications of the said notification, stood poised before the bench, ready to present his case with meticulous detail.
In response to the court’s summons, the representative of the respondent-Department, Mr. Jeevan J. Neeralgi, stepped forward, bearing a copy of the contentious notification dated 10.09.2018. With practiced precision, he laid out the text before the judge, ensuring that every word was poised for scrutiny.
The notification itself, embossed with the seal of the Government of India, emanated an aura of authority, its contents poised to shape the course of legal deliberation. As the judge perused the document, the courtroom fell into a contemplative silence, each word of the notification echoing with significance.
“[To be published in the Gazette of India, Extraordinary, Part 71, Section Sub-section Government of India Ministry of Finance Department of Revenue Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs Acti Notification No.48/2018 – Central Tax”
With a meticulous eye for detail, the judge delved into the intricacies of the notification, parsing each clause with the precision of a seasoned legal mind. The petitioner, emboldened by the prospect of clarity, eagerly awaited the judge’s interpretation, hopeful that justice would be served with the stroke of a pen.
As the proceedings stretched into the afternoon, the courtroom seemed to bask in the languid embrace of the summer sun, time itself elongating with each passing moment. Yet, amidst the sweltering heat, the pursuit of legal enlightenment remained undeterred, fueled by the unwavering commitment to uphold the principles of justice.
In the end, as the judge delivered his verdict, the courtroom erupted into a chorus of muted applause, the echoes of a legal victory reverberating through the halls of justice. And though the summer day may have been long, its significance would endure far beyond the fading twilight, immortalized in the annals of legal history.
Download PDF:
For Reference Visit:
Read Another Case law:
GST Case Law: